Write a comment

President Trump has been continuously thwarted in Congress as he seeks money to build a border wall. After all, his critics contend, he said he would make Mexico pay for the thing, so why should they vote any money forward for it, especially the tens of billions of dollars it requires?

Turns out there are some good ideas coming forward for it.

The best one, is the taxing of immigrant remittances, a straightforward exit tax taken directly from cash transmitted through the banking system. It works because the money is often earned under the table and is thus, untaxed the way other Americans's income is. It also makes sense because the cash being remitted is critical to the Mexican and Central American governments that depend on the incoming funds (in Mexico's case, more important than oil earnings), and less of it coming across gets the message across that Mexico is paying, even if not all of the remittances are sent by illegal migrants. (Most of it is.)

The other good idea would likely have a direct impact on U.S. finances, in a sort of passive way, that nevertheless could have a big effect, as well as affect only true illegal immigrants milking the system. That is the Center for Immigration Studies's idea of selling the wall to Congress, getting the funding, building the wall, and then benefiting from the fact that with fewer border crossers, there will be fewer welfare bills. Just those savings would pay for the wall, the CIS argues.

Because illegals, with their low education levels, lack of English (much lower than the world at large, by the way), resistance to assimilation, and proneness to look for a Chavista-style handout from the public fisk - are big users of welfare, no matter what the open-border activists say. Without paying a dime in taxes, this comes in their use of Medicaid, food stamps, public education, hospital emergency rooms, student financial aid, police and jail services, and even wear and tear on our infrastructure as they go to their illegal jobs.  Letting them in to stay is in fact the importation of poverty, something that drives down student test scores, bankrupts hospitals, fills jails and drains the public coffers.

Paul Sperry, in his column at the New York Post, writes:

Mexico won’t have to pay for the wall, after all. US taxpayers won’t have to pick up the tab, either. The controversial barrier, rather, will cover its own cost just by closing the border to illegal immigrants who tend to go on the federal dole.

That’s the finding of recent immigration studies showing the $18 billion wall President Trump plans to build along the southern border will pay for itself by curbing the importation of not only crime and drugs, but poverty.

“The wall could pay for itself even if it only modestly reduced illegal crossings and drug smuggling,” Steven A. Camarota, director of research at the Center for Immigration Studies, told The Post.

It's an important idea as President Trump makes his first visit to California to inspect the progress of the border wall and all its prototypes in San Diego, and sell the wall to the public. The U.S. wouldn't make any profit off ending welfare subsidies for illegals, but finding ways to do it to finance the wall should be good enough for most of the public. What's more, it's doable. In the past, any effort to get illegals off welfare rolls they are not entitled to be on has been stopped by leftwing judges, eager to beef up the Democrats' voter rolls one way or another. With illegals unable to get over at all, and many self-deporting as well, there would be no court cases to thwart the matter.

Then maybe we can get back to celebrating legal immigration and welcoming immigrants as our economy needs. Seems worth trying and President Trump would be wise to push this line of thinking during his San Diego border trip.



Read more: https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2018/03/heres_an_idea_cut_welfare_for_illegals_and_use_the_savings_to_build_the_wall.html#ixzz59SgogvDT 
Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook

 

 

FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER & FACEBOOK

 

FOLLOW ME ON FACEBOOK

 

 

 

 

Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.

Be the first to comment.

Say something here...
You are a guest ( Sign Up ? )
or post as a guest

 

 

 

Latest

11 Comments

New Rules of Engagement Announced in Syria; If Israel Hits Syria, They Get Hit Back -- IN ISRAEL

December 15, 2018
7 Comments

FEDERAL JUDGE RULES "OBAMACARE" UNCONSTITUTIONAL!

December 14, 2018
21 Comments

UKRAINE GOVERNMENT OPENS FIRE ON DONETSK AND GORLOVKA REGION

December 14, 2018
1 Comment

Obama State Dept. Provided Russia Dossier Nonsense to Senators HOURS Before Trump Sworn-in. ALL OF IT, FALSE!

December 14, 2018
2 Comments

US Embassy PROHIBITS Travel to Northern Israel ! ! !

December 14, 2018
55 Comments

I'm Wondering WHO is --ACTUALLY-- Running Our FedGov - It's not Trump

December 14, 2018
13 Comments

10 YEARS AGO TODAY – Al Gore Predicted North Pole Would Be COMPLETELY ICE FREE in Five Years

December 13, 2018
13 Comments

TURKISH ARMY BEGINS SHELLING U.S.-BACKED KURDS IN SYRIA

December 13, 2018
11 Comments

FREE Archive - Hal Turner December 12 - War within 48 Hours - Ukraine/Syria/Both

December 12, 2018
5 Comments

British Prime Minister SURVIVES "No-Confidence" Vote

December 12, 2018
4 Comments

END OF MACRON: French president faces NO CONFIDENCE vote TOMORROW - France in chaos

December 12, 2018
1 Comment

With Winter Upon Us, Seasonal Lubrication can improve performance . . .

December 12, 2018
2 Comments

Earthquake Hits Tennessee; Felt in Atlanta and farther South in GA

December 12, 2018
5 Comments

It's Official: British Prime Minster to Face No-Confidence Vote TODAY

December 12, 2018
4 Comments

British Prime Minister to be OUSTED in "No-Confidence" Vote

December 11, 2018
7 Comments

FIRST TIME IN 75 YEARS! U.S. ENDS RELIANCE ON FOREIGN OIL

December 11, 2018
7 Comments

ISRAEL PUTS TROOPS ON LEBANON BORDER; LEBANON NOW DEPLOYING TROOPS TO FACE THEM

December 11, 2018
6 Comments

UKRAINE ALERTS 90 HOSPITALS; PREPARE FOR INCOMING WOUNDED - "CLEANSING" OF "UNWANTED ELEMENTS"

December 11, 2018
2 Comments

VIDEO: Ukraine Moving more Armor for War

December 11, 2018
7 Comments

INTEL: Ukraine Government Planning FALSE FLAG ATTACK in Mariupol within 72 Hours

December 10, 2018